Discussion Questions

Chapter 3: What Kinds of Belief?

1) Elliott says, "We, too, have our revealed religion." What does he mean?

2) Can we build a "religion" around our "associations with living men and women"?

3) Neumann indicates that "unhappiness" accompanies religion. What does he mean? (Compare Martin's comment on dissatisfaction in section II) Do you agree, disagree?

4) At the same time he speaks of "satisfaction" in ". . . striving which is its own compensation." Does this contradict the idea expressed in question No. 3? What differences are there between "happiness" and "satisfaction," if any? Give examples if possible. Try to avoid merely semantic argument.

5) "Religion," says Golding, "is ever in the making." Can we find a secure orientation is such a view of religion? How?

6) The "social" interest of the Movement is expressed by Golding: "The man who has truly come to himself has come home to humanity." What does this mean? What implication has such a view for our attitudes on race, war, etc.--if any?

7) Nathanson points to the modern events that have challenged so-called "easy" optimism, etc. How then have faith in man? (Refer also to Elliott above, questions No. 1, 2)

8) Human nature is not "given" but developing (i.e., changing). Do you agree, disagree? Why?

9) What are the implications for social action, personal ethics, etc. of your agreement or disagreement in question No. 8 above?

This document is part of a larger document, "Understanding Ethical Religion," edited by Howard B. Radest.